NAVIGATING CORPORATE DISCRIMINATION: RIGHTS & REMEDIES

Introduction

The introduction sets the foundation by explaining what constitutes workplace discrimination and why it’s critical to address it. Workplace discrimination occurs when an employee is treated unfavorably due to attributes like gender, caste, religion, disability, sexual orientation, or age. This section should emphasize that such treatment not only affects an individual’s career progression, emotional well-being, and job satisfaction but also adversely impacts the overall productivity and culture of the organization. Introducing statistical data or a relevant survey can make the discussion more impactful—for instance, citing studies showing that organizations with higher inclusivity tend to have better employee retention and satisfaction rates.

1. Understanding Workplace Discrimination :

Definition of Workplace Discrimination

Workplace discrimination is any form of unjust treatment based on personal characteristics that are unrelated to job performance. It includes direct discrimination (explicit unfair treatment) and indirect discrimination (neutral policies that disadvantage specific groups). The section should stress how this treatment often results in denial of opportunities, differential pay, or harassment. Examples help make this clearer, such as when a female employee is consistently assigned clerical work rather than strategic projects because of her gender.

2. Types of Discrimination in the Workplace:

a. Gender-Based Discrimination:

• This form includes disparate treatment because of gender, covering areas like recruitment, training opportunities, pay, promotions, and work conditions. For example, a qualified female employee being passed over for promotion in favor of a male colleague with lesser qualifications is a clear instance of gender discrimination.
• Common Manifestations: This can include sexual harassment, unequal pay (gender wage gap), pregnancy discrimination, and barriers to leadership roles. Also, emphasize the stereotypes that contribute to gender bias, such as the belief that women are less suited for technical roles.

b. Racial and Caste-Based Discrimination:

• This involves unfair treatment of individuals due to their ethnicity, race, or caste. In India, caste-based discrimination is a major concern, particularly against those from Scheduled Castes (SC), Scheduled Tribes (ST), and Other Backward Classes (OBC). It could include biased treatment during recruitment, wage differences, or being given demeaning assignments.
• Examples: Address instances such as the unequal allocation of roles in companies or ostracizing individuals based on their caste.

c. Religious Discrimination:

This type of discrimination happens when an employee faces negative treatment based on their religion or religious beliefs. In some workplaces, individuals might be denied leave for religious observances or subjected to derogatory comments regarding their religious attire or practices.

Common Issues: Refusing to make accommodations for religious practices or imposing a dress code that conflicts with religious attire are typical examples.

d. Disability-Based Discrimination:

• Disability discrimination occurs when employees with disabilities are not provided reasonable accommodations to help them work effectively. It could also include refusal to hire a qualified individual solely based on their disability, rather than their capabilities.
• Reasonable Accommodation: This term refers to modifications or adjustments that enable a person with a disability to have equal employment opportunities. Examples include providing wheelchair access, screen-reading software, or flexible work hours.

e. Sexual Orientation and Gender Identity:

• LGBTQ+ individuals often face prejudice and bias due to their sexual orientation or gender identity. Discrimination in this context could include harassment, ridicule, or denial of rights and opportunities at work. Discuss the mental and emotional toll that such discrimination can have on individuals.
• Example: An employee being targeted for jokes or derogatory remarks because of their gender expression falls under this category.

f. Age-Based Discrimination:

• Often referred to as ageism, age-based discrimination typically affects older employees but can also target younger workers. For older workers, this could mean being overlooked for career advancement or denied retraining opportunities, while younger workers may be stereotyped as inexperienced.
• Manifestations: Layoffs that disproportionately target older employees, under the assumption that they are less adaptable, are a classic example.

3. Relevant Laws on Workplace Discrimination

• Constitutional Provisions:

Article 14 – Equality before Law:

a. This article guarantees equality to all persons within India, prohibiting arbitrary and discriminatory actions. It ensures that everyone is treated equally by both the government and private individuals, without any distinction.

b. Application in the Workplace: Employers cannot treat employees differently based on irrelevant distinctions, such as caste or gender.

Article 15 – Prohibition of Discrimination:

a. Article 15 ensures that no citizen is discriminated against on grounds of religion, race, caste, sex, or place of birth. It prohibits both direct and indirect discrimination by public and private entities.

b. In Practice: Employers cannot deny jobs or promotions to individuals based solely on any of these attributes.

Article 16 – Equal Employment Opportunity:
This article specifically addresses public employment, ensuring equal opportunity for all citizens. It prohibits any discrimination in public sector jobs and mandates that employment decisions be made based on merit rather than discriminatory factors.

Practical Example: A government job application process that excludes certain communities or genders is unconstitutional under this article.

• Statutory Laws:

The Equal Remuneration Act, 1976:

a. This Act mandates that men and women performing the same work or work of a similar nature must receive equal pay. The law aims to address the gender pay gap that often persists in workplaces.

Practical Example: An employer who pays male workers more than female workers for performing the same duties is violating this law.

The Rights of Persons with Disabilities Act, 2016:

a. This law mandates non-discrimination in employment opportunities for persons with disabilities. Employers are required to make reasonable accommodations to ensure that disabled employees can effectively perform their jobs.

b. Reasonable Accommodation Examples: Providing wheelchair accessibility, adaptive technologies, or modified workstations.

Sexual Harassment of Women at Workplace (Prevention, Prohibition, and Redressal) Act, 2013:

1. This Act seeks to protect women from sexual harassment at work and mandates the establishment of Internal Complaints Committees (ICCs) within organizations. It provides a detailed procedure for reporting, investigation, and redressal of complaints.

2. Requirements for Employers: All employers are obligated to create a safe working environment, raise awareness, and comply with ICC requirements.

Industrial Disputes Act, 1947:

1. This Act provides mechanisms for resolving employment disputes, including those involving discriminatory dismissals. It allows workers to file claims if they believe they have been wrongfully terminated due to prejudice.

Examples: Discriminatory practices in industrial layoffs and retrenchments can be challenged under this Act.

Your Rights Against Discrimination

Right to Equality and Non-Discrimination:

1. Employees are entitled to equal treatment in the workplace, irrespective of their caste, gender, or religion. This right ensures they are not sidelined for promotions, wages, or other work-related benefits based on discriminatory factors.

Examples: If an employee is denied opportunities for training based on gender, it violates the right to equality.

Right to Equal Pay:

1. The Equal Remuneration Act enforces this right to ensure that men and women are not discriminated against with respect to wages for similar work. This is crucial to addressing gender disparity in compensation.

Practical Implication: Employers must justify different pay scales with legitimate reasons unrelated to gender or other biases.

Right to a Safe and Harassment-Free Workplace:

1. Every employee has the right to a work environment free of harassment and discrimination. This includes physical safety as well as freedom from emotional or verbal harassment.

Application: Employers are required to have anti-harassment policies and procedures in place for reporting and investigating complaints.

Right to Reasonable Accommodation for Disabilities:

1. Under the Rights of Persons with Disabilities Act, employers must accommodate the specific needs of disabled employees. The accommodation must be reasonable, ensuring that disabled employees can perform their duties effectively.

Examples: Allowing flexible working hours or providing an ergonomic workstation to a person with a disability.

Right to Redressal:

Internal Redressal: This can involve HR departments or designated grievance cells in the organization, whereas external redressal involves approaching the labor commissioner or the courts.

Employees facing discrimination have the right to seek redressal through various legal mechanisms. These include internal grievance committees, labor courts, and civil suits.

Corporate Discrimination Lawyer in Bangalore

Remedies for Workplace Discrimination

Internal Remedies:

Filing a Complaint with HR or Grievance Cell:

1. The first step in addressing workplace discrimination is to utilize internal mechanisms like the HR department or a designated grievance committee. Organizations are required by law to handle such complaints promptly and effectively.
2. Practical Advice: Employees should maintain a record of all incidents and communications to strengthen their case.

Using Internal Committees:

1. For specific types of discrimination, such as sexual harassment, the law mandates organizations to form Internal Complaints Committees (ICCs) to handle complaints. ICCs are required to be impartial and follow a fair investigation process.
2. Importance of Internal Committees: ICCs provide a formal mechanism to ensure accountability within organizations and compliance with the law.

Legal Remedies:

Filing a Complaint with the Labour Commissioner:

1. Employees can approach the Labour Commissioner’s office for mediation or intervention when internal mechanisms fail or are unavailable. The Labour Commissioner has the authority to investigate the matter and provide solutions.
2. Process: The employee must provide proof of discrimination, such as witness statements or documentation, which will be used during mediation.

Seeking Relief Under the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947:

1. If discrimination involves termination, layoffs, or other disputes related to employment, an employee can raise an industrial dispute. The Industrial Tribunal or Labour Court can adjudicate the matter.

Example: A worker dismissed without valid reasons can seek reinstatement or compensation through this Act.

Filing a Writ Petition in High Courts:

1. Employees can approach High Courts directly via writ petitions if their fundamental rights have been violated. This approach is usually faster than filing suits in lower courts and provides a direct channel for seeking constitutional remedies.
2. Common Grounds for Writs: Violation of the right to equality or denial of basic employment rights.

Civil Suits:

1. Employees may file civil suits for compensation for damages resulting from discrimination or harassment. Such claims may include loss of wages, mental anguish, or damage to professional reputation.
2. Monetary Damages: This may cover lost income, legal expenses, and punitive damages intended to discourage future discriminatory practices.

Monetary Compensation:

1. The courts may award compensation that includes lost wages, damages for emotional trauma, or reimbursement for legal fees. This remedy aims to provide financial redress to victims and deter future occurrences.
2. Case Example: In sexual harassment cases, courts often impose heavy compensation on the employer, which also acts as a deterrent.

Supporting Case Laws

Vishaka v. State of Rajasthan (1997):

a. This case led to the establishment of the Vishaka Guidelines for preventing sexual harassment at the workplace, ultimately forming the basis of the Sexual Harassment of Women at Workplace Act, 2013.

b. Impact: It set a precedent for mandating internal redressal mechanisms within organizations.

Dina Nath Tiwari v. State of UP (1996):

a. This case established that any promotion or employment decision influenced by caste is unconstitutional under Articles 14 and 16.

b. Significance: It is a critical reference for employees facing caste-based bias in employment opportunities.

National Federation of the Blind v. Union Public Service Commission (1993):

a. In this case, the Supreme Court ruled that denying blind candidates the right to take competitive exams is discriminatory.

b. Application: It helped pave the way for disability-friendly employment practices across the public and private sectors.

Air India v. Nergesh Meerza (1981):

a. The Court ruled against discriminatory service conditions imposed on female flight attendants, such as different retirement ages and rules.

b. Significance: It underscored the importance of gender-neutral employment policies.

Lilly Thomas v. Union of India (2013):

a. This case emphasized that personal laws or religious practices cannot be used as a basis for discriminatory treatment in the workplace.

b. Significance: It reinforced secular and non-discriminatory policies in workplaces.

Steps to Take if You Experience Discrimination

Gather Evidence:

a. Gathering sufficient evidence is crucial for building a strong case. This can include:

i. Emails, messages, or written records that show discriminatory treatment.

ii. Witness statements from colleagues.

iii. Any documentation showing that opportunities were denied or different treatment was meted out.

iv. Practical Tips: Keep records of incidents, note dates, and collect any supporting documents, as they will form the basis of any complaint filed.

File a Complaint with Your Employer:

a. The first step is often to file a complaint with HR or a designated grievance cell. Internal complaints help organizations address issues internally before they escalate.

i. Process: Understand your company’s grievance redressal mechanism and follow the prescribed steps to lodge a formal complaint. Maintain a copy of all communications.

Seek Legal Help:

a. Seeking legal help is vital if internal mechanisms fail or are unresponsive. A labor lawyer can help:

i. Advise on rights and options.

ii. Draft legal notices or assist in preparing court documents.

iii. Represent the employee in hearings.

iv. Practical Guidance: Choose a lawyer experienced in employment law to understand the nuances of discrimination-related cases.

Consider Alternative Dispute Resolution (ADR):

a. Mediation or arbitration can be used as an alternative to litigation to resolve disputes more amicably and cost-effectively.

i. Advantages: ADR is less adversarial, more flexible, and often quicker. It also provides confidentiality, which can be crucial in sensitive matters of workplace discrimination.

Creating Awareness & Promoting an Inclusive Workplace :

Training and Awareness Programs:

a. To prevent discrimination, organizations must regularly conduct training programs on diversity, equity, and inclusion (DEI). Topics should include:

i. Unconscious bias training.

ii. Workshops on gender sensitivity and inclusivity.

iii. Disability awareness training.

iv. Outcome: Regular training helps reduce bias and creates an environment where employees understand the importance of inclusivity.

Encouraging Reporting Mechanisms:

a. Employees should feel confident that their complaints will be heard without fear of retaliation. Organizations can:

i. Create anonymous reporting channels.

ii. Assure confidentiality.

iii. Regularly communicate that retaliation against complainants is prohibited.

iv. Best Practices: Employers should conduct independent audits of their reporting mechanisms to ensure they are trustworthy and effective.

Zero Tolerance Policies:

a. Organizations must have strict anti-discrimination and anti-harassment policies, which clearly outline unacceptable behaviors and consequences.

i. Enforcement: Consistent application of these policies without favoritism or bias shows the organization’s commitment to an inclusive workplace.

ii. Examples: Setting up robust disciplinary actions for discriminatory behavior, conducting regular reviews of workplace practices, and publicly affirming a zero-tolerance stance.

Conclusion

The conclusion should reiterate that every employee deserves to work in an environment free from discrimination. It’s essential to be informed about your rights and the legal remedies available. Discrimination is not just an individual issue; addressing it fosters a more inclusive and equitable workplace culture that benefits everyone. Encouraging readers to speak up against unfair practices, both for themselves and on behalf of others, will empower them to take action. Lastly, a note on the need for employers to continuously evaluate and improve their workplace practices will conclude the discussion on a proactive note.

---

Disclaimer:

The information provided in this article is for general informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. While efforts have been made to ensure the accuracy of the content, Bisani Legal and its representatives are not responsible for any errors or omissions, or for any outcomes resulting from reliance on this information. Readers are advised to consult a qualified legal professional for specific legal guidance related to their individual property matters. The use of this article does not establish an attorney-client relationship between the reader and BisaniLegal.

---

Published by: Mr. Saket bisani
Date: 06/03/2025